The Wesleyan Band Meeting Can Cure Our Addiction-Filled Culture
Photo by cottonbro studio
If you weren’t an addict, you probably are one by now.
I'm not sure if we thought through all the implications of putting a highly addictive portable computer in everyone's pocket. I'm 34, and I grew up in the time right before smartphones. When I was growing up, addiction was viewed as a problem for immoral people—those drunks and druggies who never seemed capable of pulling their lives together. Addiction, so many of us thought, was over there on the other side of town.
Many of us have assumed we don’t have addictive tendencies. Perhaps we still think that. But I don’t think we can assume that anymore.
Smartphones are ubiquitous now—not only in America, but throughout the world. We fill our smartphones with addictive apps for social media and shopping. To be blunt, we should all assume that we all live with some degree of addictive tendency.
Addictions damage our lives in various ways. What can the church do to address this widespread issue? One addiction treatment that has long been recognized for its effectiveness is the 12-step program. If we take a look at the 12 steps, we will notice striking similarities between them and the Wesleyan Band meeting questions. Churches of the Wesleyan tradition already have a powerful tool at their disposal to address addiction. Whether or not a person participates in an actual 12-step program, he or she can still participate in practices—through the Wesleyan Band meeting—that can reduce addictive tendencies. In fact, I believe the Wesleyan Band meeting can cure our addiction-filled culture.
We must take an honest look at the problem. We can't stop looking at our phones. When there is a lull in conversation, we look at our phones. Before Texas banned phones in school, I worked as an educator in the public school system. I regularly caught my students endlessly scrolling reels on Instagram. These videos have also been shown to be addictive.
Smartphones are no less than a Pandora’s box. They have given us unprecedented access to pornography, gambling, and shopping. What is the best path forward to help us face and deal with addiction?
We may be tempted to say, “Well, I’m just like my phone and social media. That’s not so bad. I’m not as bad as the compulsive gambler or shopper.” In my work with recovering drug and alcohol addicts, I’ve learned that this line of thinking is a form of denial, a hallmark of an addict. When we minimize our problems by comparing ourselves to others who are “worse,” we essentially push away help and refuse to address our problems. Yes, even phone addiction is a problem.
All addictions are a problem because they take us away from connection with God and with others. We run to addictions to fill hurts and holes in our hearts; this just exacerbates our issues. The more time we spend on our phones, the less time we spend interacting with our spouses, children, and friends. When we choose our devices, we take ourselves away from them. We may be present physically, but we are emotionally absent. That is a problem because God made us for connection.
I admit, phones and technological devices are low-hanging fruit. It is easy to say that we all at least have some degree of an unhealthy attachment to our smartphones. However, addiction comes in many different forms. Work addiction is real. Many of us find our purpose and identity in work. Since we often don't know how to have meaningful relationships outside of work, we then tend to avoid things that are not part of our work. Sports are a common source of addictive behavior. There is a demonstrated and unfortunate connection between football and addiction; it's been a topic of conversation with former football players.
Here in Texas, football is a big deal. Players work out all summer, they practice hard, and then run onto the field with the Friday night lights shining down on them. Ask any of them; it is quite a high. Athletes, parents, friends, and fans come on Friday night (for high school football) or Saturday (for college football) to experience the high. When the season ends, or a career ends, life for players can seem depressing. The thing that gave players, and even fans, a sense of purpose and identity, the thing that made them high, is gone.
Sports culture in America and across the world has become addictive. As Damien Pearse says, the thrill of scoring in sports is “akin to cocaine use.” The unpredictability of sports and the intense dopamine responses also mean that watching sports can be addictive. Furthermore, the recent increase in sports betting creates additional serious problems that commonly lead to addiction. Even youth sports have become part of the problem. Many parents have gone into debt to help pay for extracurricular activities. And every pastor knows our culture's unhealthy attachment to youth sports has affected church attendance. Church attendance among families has decreased as participation in youth sports has increased. At worst, our addictive tendencies, at best our disordered priorities, damage our connections with God and with the body of Christ.
The 12-step program has been the gold standard of addiction treatment for many decades. A quick reading of the 12 steps shows that it is based on Christian principles. That is a large part of why it works.
Does that mean we all must join a 12-step group? Some people would benefit from a 12-step program, especially those with substance addictions or addictions such as shopping or pornography. However, I believe many of us would be able to better manage our addictive tendencies by faithfully participating in a Wesleyan Band meeting.
The Band meeting can be thought of as a mini-12-step meeting, but it is more than that. If our decaying, addiction-filled culture is to get better, we as the church must model the first step of healing to the world and admit that not only do we need help with our addictive tendencies, but we need a Savior. This is the beginning of healing. There is no way forward without admitting our sin and great need for Jesus. We must also admit that we need our brothers and sisters in Christ. Confession of sin and admission of need is the counterintuitive power of the Band meeting.
Admitting powerlessness is the first step of the 12-steps; the first and fourth questions of the Wesleyan Band meeting echo this opportunity for honesty: 1. How is it with your soul? 4. Do you have any sin to confess? Question four also directly corresponds with the fifth step of the 12-steps, which says to confess to others the “exact nature of our wrongs.”
Step four of the 12-steps says we must make a “fearless moral inventory” of ourselves. All five questions of the Wesleyan Band meeting make a moral inventory of a person. Questions two, four, and five are like a scalpel that removes the shame and guilt of our wounded soul: 2. What are your successes and struggles? 4. Do you have any sin to confess? 5. Is there anything you desire to keep secret? In every meeting, we continue to make a moral inventory of ourselves, which enables us to live a sober life.
But the Band meeting is not only for confessing sin and need. We pray with others for increased holiness (which corresponds to steps six, seven, and eleven of the 12-steps). We receive encouragement from our Bandmates for the relational amends that may need to be made with people in our lives (steps eight and nine of the 12-step). And most importantly, we pronounce and receive the forgiveness of Christ over one another (step 12).
We continue this process over and over—continuing to take inventory and admitting when we have sinned (step ten) and receiving God's grace and forgiveness. Through this process, we find healing. We gain clarity where we once had a veil over our eyes. Chains are broken and cycles of sin are disrupted. The phrase "nothing will ever change" transforms into "things are getting better." Forgiveness and love burst forth like rivers breaking through a dam, washing away the dirt of shame and guilt. By God's grace and the Holy Spirit, we are empowered to live holy lives, free from the grips of addiction.
There is always a temptation to think we don't need this. But pride comes before the fall (Proverbs 16:18). It is pride that leads us into believing that things aren't "that bad," or that we don't need to confess sins or practice self-examination. We become fooled into thinking we can handle things on our own; we don't need brothers and sisters in Christ, and falling into the cycle of sin is inevitable.
My hope is that every church rediscovers the power of the Wesleyan Band meeting. As good as simple small groups and Bible studies can be, the Band meeting is more suitable to dig into and clean out our souls. Our problem in the church is not a lack of information. Rather, it is that our hearts need healing. The addictions that have become so pervasive in our lives bring darkness and decay, one way or another. Our families, our churches, and our culture waste away while our eyes are glued to reels. We have a problem, and it is serious.
Band meetings have always been important; perhaps they are increasing in importance as our culture encourages us to succumb to various high-powered addictions. May the church, led by the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, show a better path forward.
Wesley Ross Harris is the pastor of Hubbard Methodist Church in Hubbard, Texas. He also works with recovering drug and alcohol addicts at a rehab center in Hubbard.