Rediscovering the Pastor Theologian in the Wesleyan Methodist Movement
Photo by Brett Jordan on Unsplash
In their book, The Pastor as Public Theologian, Kevin Vanhoozer and Owen Strachan recall the funny story of a couple visiting Greyfriars Kirk in Edinburgh. Stumbling upon a certain headstone, “the wife suddenly blurted out, ‘Look, honey: they buried two people in one grave!’ ‘What makes you think that?’ asked her husband. The woman replied: ‘It says so right here: ‘Here lies a pastor and a theologian.’” (Vanhoozer and Strachan 2020, 79)
As a pastor with a Ph.D., people usually assume my pastorate is a placeholder till my academic ship comes in. Just in case that ship never comes, the pastorate is reduced, in the eyes of some, to the backup career of a wannabe professor. And within Wesleyan circles, at least, having a Ph.D. or being a theologian is no badge of honor. In my experience, most see it as a distraction and probably useless in the real world. Mumbo jumbo, the wine of the philosophers. Real theologians are at universities, real pastors at local churches, and God forbid you stumble upon them outside their cages.
I have always considered this way of thinking wrongheaded. Perhaps it is time for a fresh emphasis on the pastor theologian in the Wesleyan Methodist movement. Minimally this means more theological rigor in the pastorate, but it should also include a greater valuation of constructive theology for the wider Church by those who are grounded in pastoral work for the local church. For the sake of space, I will focus on the former.
Defining the Pastor Theologian
Theologians are usually understood as those having a professional or expert understanding of at least some issues involved in thinking about God and who contribute constructively to that conversation through teaching and sometimes writing. Pastors, on the other hand, are regarded as those interested and trained in spreading the gospel and shepherding a community of believers via certain sacramental duties. Pastor theologians, then, may be defined reductively as those who are both pastors and theologians, where those distinct interests and practices may or may not intersect in various ways with varying degrees. In other words, some pastor theologians may live in two distinct worlds where their theological expertise is unrelated to the work they do in their local church. For others, their theological expertise might be driven by their pastoral work or their pastoral work heavily influenced by their theological proficiency.
John Wesley was of the variety driven by pastoral interests. Albert Outler famously characterized him as a “folk theologian,” whose task Outler defined as “the simplification of the great issues…on behalf of the common people” (Wesleyan Theological Heritage, 112). This is a charming description and not wrong. However, one of the most unstudied features of John Wesley is his value as a hardcore, philosophy-slinging theologian. He was so skilled at translating his theological gems into pastoral care that many, today, pass by them, covered in the dirt and grime of real life as they are, never noticing they only cut as deep as they do ministerially because they are as sharp as they are theologically. Missing this relationship has fostered a movement that blushes at theological precision while simultaneously frustrated at the inability of its pastors to defend its cherished dogmas.
Why We Need Pastor Theologians
Much of the problem concerns perspective. In some ways, every pastor is a theologian functionally, but this does not mean he or she is a good theologian. Pastors, to at least some degree, need to know why being a good theologian matters. Other important reasons might be given, but let me provide two that focus on theological thinking as an aesthetic form of worship and two that speak to pragmatic concerns.
1) The Sanctified Intellect as Worship
First, God designed the working intellect for his purposes. It is an essential element of the human architecture, a part of God’s own being stamped upon our rational souls, an instrument meant to be played in the symphony of the Church’s worship. Doing theological work, wrote John Webster, “is that delightful activity in which the Church praises God by ordering its thinking towards the gospel of Christ” (Holiness 2003, 8), to which we might add bringing our thoughts, conceptions, and imaginations into conformity with God.
The intellect is a faculty for exploring the contours of reality, especially the reality of God since God’s reality informs and grounds everything else (Psalm 19:1–2; Romans 1:20). This is not an arrogant undertaking! It is the loving God with all our minds (Matthew 22:37). It is, as Paul encouraged, to think about whatsoever is true, pure, lovely, and excellent (Philippians 4:8). We may study what we love, not to get what we love under control but to get what we love into focus, to see more of it, to revel in it a little longer, to see some feature of it we had not noticed before. We explore what is familiar to remember and what is unfamiliar to enjoy the pleasant surprise of what is just around the corner. There is a God-ordained beauty in this enterprise, canonized in scripture by feasts, festivals, confessions, and various practices.
2) Intellectual Worship as Local Worship
Second, this delightful activity belongs to the local church. Why should researchers and professors have all the joy of exploring the deep things of God, the simple beauties of the theological story, the harmonies of God’s presentations to humanity, the applications of language to mystery? This treats theology like medical training. “Patients need not bother themselves with the boring study of medicine. Let the doctors do that and then tell everyone else what treatments they should and should not implement.”
Instead, we might think of theology, in one sense, like a national park, protected and preserved so that citizens may safely and freely run through its trails, camp near its rivers, learn its landscape, and relax in its beauty. God is beautiful and wonderful, and he has made himself known, yet, in some cases, the local church has never set foot in the park, perhaps not knowing there is anything more to explore beyond what can be seen from their driveways. The unfortunate result of this is that when God becomes boring and unattractive, churches will replace contemplating him with coffee shops, ugly sweater Sundays, and programs that make us feel relevant.
God is infinitely beautiful, but some local churches present themselves as if all that could be understood of God was accomplished in a track thirty years ago. To no surprise, love grows cold, getting into heaven becomes enough, and contemplating it is hardly worth the discipline.
3) Pastors as Responsible Theological Agents
Third, pastors bear responsibility for cultivating a culture of theological aesthetics at the local level. Imagine gathering weekly with the local Botanist Society where games are played, coffee served, fellowship had, and the chairman of each meeting gives a long speech on how, practically, to think yourself an adequate keeper of plants, but where the plants themselves are never studied, never explored, never smelt, and the mystery of them never wondered at. It could be argued it is not plants they love but, perhaps, something else, like a presentable yard or the coffee or the fellowship or the chairman.
At the local level of pastoral ministry, it is God himself that is beautiful beyond measure. His glory needs no assistance, no touch-ups, no stand-ins. Whatever else pastors may do, they should always have an eye toward washing any dirty windows that obscure God's glory, that keep people from seeing God as he truly is. Paul prayed for the Colossians to increase in the knowledge of God and be filled with the knowledge of his will (Colossians 1:9–10), things he understood as a "depth of riches" (Romans 11:33 ESV), but he did not stop there. He went on to explain what these things were, and so should the pastor. Yet pastors who do not themselves see clearly who God is, understand the works he does, or recognize the loveliness of both, will be tempted, unwittingly perhaps, to exchange the glory of God for a lie (such as human charisma). If it is not God the people want, we pastors will have to be content with that unhappy task of knocking the dust off our sneakers and getting on with Kingdom stuff.
4) Pastors as Able Practitioners
Finally, the importance of theology is not just in the content learned, which in some cases may be very limited, but also in the intellectual habits needed to process complex questions, issues, or sets of information related to ministerial situations. Theology is, in part, learning to discipline the mind to recognize what is true, explore what is possible, and resolve what is complicated, all within the context of who God is and how God has worked to save us—a practical undertaking.
Every believer’s struggle to “flee the wrath to come” (Matthew 3:7 KJV) and make their way to glory is fraught with problems that need various forms of resolution. Cue the pastor! Among other things, this means being able to think and instruct. Consider the qualifications for elders listed by Paul in response to the Judaizers who were troubling local churches. “[Elders] must hold firm to the trustworthy word as taught, so that he may be able to give instruction in sound doctrine and also to rebuke those who contradict it” (Titus 1:9 ESV). Likewise, Timothy was to present himself as one approved by God, “a worker who has no need to be ashamed, rightly handling the word of truth,” which Paul related to the “babble” of those who were “upsetting the faith of some” (2 Timothy 2:15–18 ESV). And in Hebrews, skill and training in the word of righteousness is necessary for distinguishing good from evil and for helping believers “go on to maturity” (Hebrews 5:11–14; 6:1 ESV).
Each of these exhortations requires two things: an understanding of what the gospel is in its relations (to the Old Testament, sin, culture, human nature, Christ, etc.) and of what the threats are when they arrive in their various disguises and flavors (Judaizers, Docetists, Gnostics, Mormons, Christian Nationalists). Pastors must be on their toes, so to speak, not only in the posture of their hearts but also in the preparedness and ability of their intellects to assess what is needed at the intersection of gospel and life.
Conclusion
Doing good theology as a pastor means understanding and presenting things well enough for congregants to be able to bask in who God is and what God has done. Sometimes this means swatting at those pesky bad theologies that buzz around the mind of the church, and sometimes it means painting a picture of an old scene in brighter colors. This assumes in theory that the pastor has a good theological foundation and operating system from which to work, but which, unfortunately, cannot be assumed in reality. It must be cultivated!
Weak minds in the pastorate may be an opportunity for grace and the miraculous, and thank God, we are not without supply, but they are not a reason for applause nor a virtue. The disciples were not recognized as men of learning by people of high standing, but this does not mean they were not learned (Ac 4:13). They had three years of on-site training, teaching, and internship with Jesus. Whatever else they were when they began to follow, they were well-versed when sent, and we don't have time to talk about Paul, whose writings are still proving intellectually complex (and relevant) after two millennia (2 Pet 3:16).
Degrees or not, the pastor must work to remedy the defects of his or her intellect, and a new emphasis on the importance of pastor theologians may help. For this reason, we are launching the Society of Wesleyan Pastor Theologians on March 11 with the Wesleyan Theological Society, and we hope you will join us or send your pastors to get involved.
We cordially invite you to attend the launch of the Society of Wesleyan Pastor Theologians on March 11, 2026, from 2:00-5:00 pm at Southern Nazarene University in Bethany, Oklahoma. “SWPT” is a new affiliate society of the Wesleyan Theological Society. You can register for more information at SWPT Launch or email us at admin@wesleyanpastortheologians.org.
Kenny Johnston is a PhD candidate at the London School of Theology and the Pastor of First Wesleyan Church in Gastonia, NC.